Look above a bunch of posts. read most of them too XD

I based the sylesti off the Sylestia Logo sign X3 They're rather adorbes actually~

ahh, thank you! sorry you can't participate though :T

getting right to work though!

I very much like how sparkly and shiny these sylesties are, they represent Sylestia in a peppy sparkly way.

For visibles, they may not've had the most, but the simplicity of the design is very appealing so I'll have to say 3/5

For Creativity, I wouldn't have imagined you using a Bulbori, even though it's like the logo, the Bulbori is something new. 3/5

For overall design, I think you appealed well to the eye and it just looks clean, simple, and beautiful. 5/5

Your Total (From me, don't forget the other judges XD): 11/15

Here is my entry, I hope it looks nice enough for all of you =) I had fun doing it and I definitively want to hug him/her *.* (posting both versions ^^)


so I went on basis of the nice drake like creature that form the S of sylestia, so nephini, and colour scheme blue, and yellow because it's blue's complementary colour =P : here !



and

Im so glad you like my design, I forgot to ping the other judges XC my bads X3

to the other judges, please look above for my design X3

Damn, forgot about pinging ... Still fumbling around here =P

By the way, your design was really neat Jai, I just noticed it ^^ I like how clean it is =)

Jai
Yes the design is is nice and impressive, shiny and well cute.

Yet for creativity sorry, I'm a bit harsh on coloring. It is just a single blue and then yellow, if you had different shadings, and/or perhaps different genes to look like one id give it a higher score. I never seen a bulbori use for something like this nor used for looking like a dragon so I will give you credit for that. Yet in this section 2/5.

For visibles, you did great. I like to see people who use little as possible. You created an entry with two vis and give you props for that so... 4/5

Overall. Overall to me, because as I stated with creativity it's too simple for me. I would like to see more than that and I know you can do more than that. I have seen your designs. So I would have to give you a 4/5 cause I don't want to give you a too low of a grade. It's not fair to give you a low grade ether because you tried doing something that you never tried before so thus the grade I have given it.

Total: 10/15

Jai

Visibles 2/5 - I'm a bit of a minimalist myself but this design looks like it could have used one more gene/mutation. It's a nice simple design and i'm a huge fan of the jewelled wings but I really would have used more visibles!

Creativity - 4/5 I agree with Purple on this. I wasn't expecting somebody to choose a bulbori as a mascot for Sylestia.

Overall design - 3/5 The only thing that really dragged your mark down was the lack of visables. A gene would have been the perfect touch! It's a beautiful simplistic design but it really could have used that extra little push. Other than that, well done :o)

***I feel like there should be a Colors mark as well. It's an incredibly essential part of every design!***
Colours - 5/5 You choose very nice complementary colours for this. Maybe I would have used a dark violet/indigo with yellow or a blue with orange/red. The blue and yellow stand out maybe a little too much for my liking but overall very well selected colours, even though modelled after the logo ^-^

(Colors don't count then? ^^^)

Total: 9/15

Thanks X3 so... is that a 14/15? or do we have to change it to 14/20 due to the color catergory we are apparently adding, and if so... I guess PurpleStarlightWolf has to redo my judging....*shrugs* either way, thanks for your opinion and rating!