This Cartato approves of these Lunemaras.

I agree with the others that don't like the new lines... because they look less moth and more weird hybrid human bug thing. I know I didn't have many lunes, but I absolutely loved the branch wings and firefly butt. Now, the firefly butt looks like it's coming out of a hairy arm or something and it just looks weird. I don't like the face/head at all, this is the most off-putting thing about the remake. The arms should be spaced out down the body... they are still pretty much the same as before, all bunched together and you can't tell them apart.
I just do not care for these at all. They are kinda creepy. I've put all mine for sale. So sad bc that patriotic was one of my favorite pets I owned pre-revamp. :(

I'm worried I'm goanna mess up my baby girl's colors

I prefer the new branch wings.

My dislike on the design is the arms.
Too humanoid to me. Still they are cute.

I like the new themed colors

I like the new.

Link: https://www.sylestia.com/forums/?thread=49886&page=8#77 Author: SpaceElf1 Time Posted: 8/15/2017 at 1:43 AM Re the list of proposed Theme changes-- I spent a lot of time staring at the Anthias palette when I was breeding for the first 6 Vis, and IMO the new palette is decidedly superior to the old one. The new Autumn Night palette has, to me, a washed-out look, and it has become mostly "autumn" and very little "night." I think the old palette is more vibrant and is better balanced between the autumn colors and the night colors. The new Blazing Fireworks seems to blaze just a bit more than that Theme did before. Thumbs up. I like the little changes in Bottled Moonlight's Eye Color and AC2, but I'm not sure about switching the G1 color from pale gold to blue. Perhaps consider keeping the G1 color as it is but increasing the saturation of the AC color (and shifting it a bit into the red): The new Candlelit looks good overall, but may be just a bit too orange. Perhaps your could really desaturate the M2 color to restore balance. This instead of this To me, the new Canna Annjee seems just a bit too crimson, though I definitely like the new M1 and M3 colors. For the Early Bloom, I like the subtle changes, but turning the G1 color from pink to yellow makes some G1 traits hard to see. New Fairy Lights looks nice with more gold and less red, but instead of switching AC1 from red to gold, how about switching M2 from red to gold? From this to this Heck, maybe even switch both AC1 and M2 to gold. More later, I hope.

I did notice a comment made on the BM Lunes, so I figure I should counter-state that I greatly prefer the current idea for them. It stays more true to Fox's original design that I loved enough to invest a Maxed Stats project for. Already that's been a 50+ Prismatic philter investment so I do have a lot riding on the fate of this theme. .__.;


Sorry, Spelf! But the proposed change to the accent really kills the subtle beauty of the wings since the color is way too close to the base wing color. I'll use Koi to point this out since it's great for testing the color trio.



Keep in mind that Koi is the most "in-your-face-this-trait-has-three-colors" for the wings, so those with more subtle changes suffer a lot worse with this suggestion.

Id like the original anthias to remain the same IMO

I like the new ones better. Thanks again!

Im not opposed to this I quite like the lunes now

i feel a bit more comfortable talking about what i don't like about the new lunes, but i would like to point out what i do like. i hope all this back and forth helps improve revamps and stuff.
anyway, what i like about the new lunes (im using my lune beebe's colors and stuff for examples):
1. the line art is very well done. the artist did a great job. i may not agree with the final product but as a fellow artist i can still say its very nice.

i was really worried one of my favorite hatchings was going to lose it's charm, but hes still begging to be picked up and hugged ^_^
2. tri color gene is very cute!

i was very disapointed with the lunes and how they only had frosted tips for that gene slot and this made me very happy. it also uses the accent color2 which i was excited to see implemented. i can't wait to see lunes with this gene.
3. lunar garb is beautiful!

i'm a sucker for this site's armor and luna themed mutations and this is my new favorite of the luna stuff.
4. LADY BUG WING MUTATION IS EFFECTED BY THE WING GENE

I WAS SO HAPPY WHEN I SAW THIS! yes its very little and i will use this to segway into my dislikes but the fact that the wing genes actually effect one of my favorite lune mutations even just a little made my day. i would always get so disappointed when playing with the generator and things wouldn't show up on the lady bug wings.

the things i don't like (using my lune blue boi cause i love love love him and this revamp just breaks my heart when i look at him now):
1. wing gene still doesn't have a impact on the lady bug mutation.

in the example i used for what i like it was valentines lace i used. this is faded glow light. i went though all the genes (the new ones as well) and very few feel they are impacting on the mutation. the only way to really see it most of the time is to have a very drastic change in color. how ever this is not needed at all for ANY of the other wings. side note: while going though the wings i noticed branch wings are still unaffected by gene mutations. im a little sad it seems the "fix" for this was to have the gene effect the antennae but this isnt noticeable on the lady bug or branch ones, so making a branch lune means not bothering with the wing gene at all making a 6 vis... pointless to me.
2. forest spirit feels too much.

don't get me wrong i got very excited about this when i saw it in the generator but it just feels so out there and the fact i can't see half of the wings- something i would think is important for this pet- just makes me think a strait forest spirit lune isn't the nicest to look at. THIS IS 100% ME! if you like it thats cool i just feel its... too much. we lose most of the art work the artist did on the wings to the very human looking arms (which i might add is the BIGGEST mutation in that slot). its nice. pretty even. but i personally think it needs to calm down.
3. spots.
someone else already touched on this and they share my exact feels about those spots. so i won't go any further.
4. blue boi.

this is 1000000% personal. i never liked the lunes, they are one of my lest favorite pets, but the fact that a very simple 1 vis pet could look so pretty and be my favorite pet out of the idk how many made the lunes a respectable favorite. how ever after the revamp he lost the "interested" or sort of excited look he had with his posture and his big eyes are still big but compared to the size of his head they feel less "big and full" and feel more "bug eyed". it might just be me but the old lunes had a sense of excited to them that the new ones don't have. its like a problem i have with the lupora- how the males look so uninterested or sorta broody. the lunes went from "excited to see you/interested in what you're doing" to a blank expression. it feels like a whole new pet rather then updated art.

okay, thats all im going to say. a lot of people have the same opinions as me (but good and bad) so i'll just end it here. also sorry if the images are too big, im not used to posting on the forum anymore...
again i hope all the back and forth helps contribute to new revamps and art updates in the future.